top of page

Stop Overthinking: What Analysis Paralysis Is (and How to Get Unstuck)


You know that feeling when you’re stuck in your head—replaying every option, running every scenario, trying to predict the “right” outcome—until you’re exhausted… and still haven’t decided?

That’s analysis paralysis. And it’s way more common than people admit.

At Be Well Collective, we see this as a very human response to pressure. Overthinking usually isn’t the problem—it’s the strategy your system uses when it doesn’t feel safe to choose.

Let’s talk about what’s happening and how to move forward with more clarity and less stress.


When overthinking pause breathe and make a choice
When overthinking pause breathe and make a choice

What Is Analysis Paralysis?

Analysis paralysis is when you get stuck in overthinking and can’t take action or make a decision. It often looks like:

  • researching endlessly

  • making lists but not choosing

  • asking everyone for input (and feeling worse after)

  • procrastinating because you “don’t feel ready”

  • feeling anxious, irritable, or mentally tired from the back-and-forth

In short: your brain stays busy, but your life doesn’t move.


Why Overthinking Happens

Overthinking is usually trying to protect you from something—like:

  • Making a mistake

  • Regret

  • Disappointing someone

  • Being judged

  • Failing

  • Losing control

It’s often connected to perfectionism, anxiety, or past experiences where making the “wrong” choice had consequences (or felt like it did). The brain learns: If I think hard enough, I can prevent pain.

The problem is… thinking isn’t the same as deciding.


Common Ways Analysis Paralysis Shows Up

You don’t need a life-changing decision for this to happen. It can show up in:

  • Work: over-editing, delaying emails, stalling on projects

  • Relationships: feeling stuck about whether to commit, leave, or have the hard conversation

  • Parenting: questioning every choice, googling everything, fearing you’ll “mess it up”

  • Health: spiraling about symptoms, supplements, providers, “the best” plan

  • Everyday life: small choices feeling weirdly heavy (what to wear, what to eat, where to go)


How to Get Unstuck (Without Needing the Perfect Answer)

1) Name what’s happening (and lower the stakes)

Try this phrase:“I’m in analysis paralysis. This feels high-stakes, but I can make a ‘good enough’ choice.”

Your brain often needs permission to stop treating the decision like a threat.


2) Decide what kind of decision this is

Ask:

  • Is this reversible? (Most decisions are.)

  • Will this matter in 6 months?

  • Is this a preference decision or a values decision?

If it’s reversible or low-impact, don’t give it a high-impact process.


3) Limit your options on purpose

More options = more overwhelm.

Try:

  • pick your top 2–3 choices only

  • stop researching after 20–30 minutes

  • choose based on “most aligned,” not “most perfect”

A simple rule: If two options are both reasonable, choose the one you’ll actually start.


4) Set a decision deadline (and a tiny next step)

Overthinking loves open-ended time.

Try:

  • “I’m deciding by 5pm today.”

  • “I’m doing one step in 10 minutes.”

Then make the next step small, like:

  • send the email

  • book the appointment

  • outline the plan

  • have the first conversation

  • pick one option and test it for a week


5) Use the “experiment” mindset

Instead of: “What’s the right choice?”Try: “What’s the next experiment?”

Experiments create motion. Motion creates clarity.

Examples:

  • “I’ll try this routine for 7 days.”

  • “I’ll apply to 3 jobs, not 30.”

  • “I’ll take one class and reassess next month.”


6) Choose, then commit (stop re-opening the tab)

After you decide, overthinking often tries to renegotiate.

Try:

  • “This is my choice for now.”

  • “I don’t need certainty to move forward.”

  • “I can adjust later.”

A powerful practice is to stop polling people after you’ve decided—because seeking more input often reactivates doubt.



A Gentle Reminder: Overthinking Usually Means You Care

You’re not “too much.” You’re not broken. If you’re stuck, it’s often because the decision represents something important—security, identity, belonging, success, being loved.

Sometimes the most supportive question isn’t “What should I do?” but:“What am I afraid will happen if I choose?”

That’s where real clarity starts.


When to Get Support

If analysis paralysis is constant—affecting sleep, relationships, work, or your ability to function—it can be helpful to talk with a therapist. Overthinking can be connected to anxiety, perfectionism, OCD patterns, depression, or ADHD-related executive functioning struggles. Support can help you understand your pattern and build tools that actually work for your brain.


Work With Be Well Collective | Audrey Malone, LCSW

If you’re tired of living in your head and ready to feel more confident in your choices, we’re here.

bottom of page